If one considers the minutes of the Reserve Bank of Australia’s November board meeting it is very difficult to see how our economists can be so optimistic that Australia will not have a recession.
It is quite obvious that the Australian economy will have at least two quarters of negative growth over the next year. Whether these follow each other thus meeting the definition of a recession is neither here nor there. What is clear is that we are in the middle of the worst slump in twenty years with household wealth sharply down and levels of debt much greater.
Many believe that the RBA’s interest rate cuts, the fiscal measures by the government and the low Australian dollar will come to our rescue. But the fact is that interest rates are still much too high, being only at neutral levels at best and the weak Australian dollar will take a while until it makes us more competitive.
The government’s $10 billion spending package (if it is not simply saved by worried households) will have only a short term effect.
The burden has now fallen on the government to boost spending on public infrastructure but this will not happen before at least six to twelve months.
At the same time we have collapsing export prices, a very weak export market since at least the early nineties, much reduced credit availabilities, rapidly slowing business investment and a huge cut to household wealth.
All of this is happening before unemployment has even started to rise.
Despite all of this the RBA feels that “the most recent information suggested that the risks to the outlook remained to the downside”.
If this is not a recession then what is?
Indeed, the first hint that the economy could actually slip into a recession was the October National Australia Bank business survey issued last week. That showed that business confidence had slumped to levels even lower than during the early nineties recession.
The RBA has wisely picked up that “given the changing balance of risks there was an advantage of moving the setting of monetary policy quickly to a neutral position”.
This is incredible. The RBA only considers that official interest rates are back to a “neutral” setting. Since we are teetering on the brink of recession it just highlights how much further the RBA has to go.
This is why it will cut rates by at least 75 basis points at the meeting early next month and in my view the rate cut should be closer to a whole percentage point if not more. In England rates were cut by 1.5% this month.
It is absolutely imperative that we push business and housing interest rates to below long run average levels as soon as we can.